ADPAN Welcomes the Public Release of the Malanjum Committee Report and Urges Malaysia to Finish the Journey to Full Abolition of the Death Penalty

The Anti Death Penalty Asia Network (ADPAN) commends the Government of Malaysia for declassifying and releasing to the public the report on the Study of Alternative Sentences for Mandatory Death Penalty. The report was prepared in 2020 by the Special Committee chaired by former Chief Justice Tan Sri Richard Malanjum, and laid the groundwork for the abolition of the mandatory death penalty in 2023.

The report has remained classified for 6 years. Its release now allows Malaysians, for the first time, to read the evidence and reasoning behind one of the most significant criminal justice reforms in the country and the Asia-Pacific region. ADPAN hopes this marks a lasting turn towards openness and transparency, including public access to the information and evidence that shape death penalty laws, policies, and practices in Malaysia. 

The Special Committee, made up of former senior judges, a former Solicitor General, prison officials, academics, and practitioners, carried out its study between September 2019 and January 2020. Its conclusions point clearly beyond the reforms eventually enacted in 2023. 

In summary, the Committee’s first recommendation, grounded on the principle of proportionality, was that the death penalty should be kept, at the court’s discretion, only for offences that cause death. Applying this principle, the Committee recommended that drug trafficking under Section 39B of the Dangerous Drugs Act 1952 no longer carry the death penalty, replacing it with imprisonment. The report noted that of the 1305 people on death row in January 2020, 918 (about 70%) had been sentenced for drug trafficking, and 551 were foreign nationals. The Committee’s second recommendation was that restorative justice be built into Malaysia’s criminal justice system. While NGOs, legal experts, and the members of the international community have called for the full abolition of the death penalty, the Committee was not mandated within its terms of reference to look into it, but recommended that the Government study the question comprehensively and in depth. 

The Abolition of Mandatory Death Penalty Act 2023 (Act 846) and the resentencing exercise under Act 847 were landmark steps, and ADPAN recognises the Government’s courage in taking them. Hundreds of people have since had their death sentences commuted by the Federal Court. But the report shows there recommendations that have yet to be taken forward. In addition, ADPAN opposes whipping, which the Committee proposed as an alternative punishment carried out with imprisonment, as a cruel, inhuman, and degrading punishment incompatible with international human rights standards. 

In October 2026, ADPAN, Monash University Malaysia, and Eleos Justice (Monash University) published Rethinking Capital Punishment for Drug Offences In Malaysia, a policy brief based on legal research and focus group discussions (FGDs). Some of the findings of the policy brief are consistent with the Committee’s recommendations. The research found that the dominant view across all groups was that the death penalty should not apply to drug trafficking. Among others, participants in the FGDs cited distrust in the institutions that administer the death penalty, raising concerns such as corruption, unequal access to justice, inconsistent sentencing, and discriminatory enforcement of law. 

More importantly, participants demonstrated a strong belief in rehabilitation, not the gallows. Participants believed that society should try to reform people before giving up on them, and called for a response that tackles poverty, coercion, drug dependence, and mental health problems which draw people into drugs. 

This echoes the Committee’s report, which records that restorative justice and rehabilitative approaches were “discussed extensively” with stakeholders. Those consulted told the Committee that many people convicted of trafficking were drug mules who deserved a second chance, that drug dependence should be treated as an illness rather than punished, and that places of detention should offer counselling, education, vocational training, and mental health care.

With that, it is time for Malaysia to take a bold step forward, building on the momentum, to abolish the death penalty for drug trafficking and all other offences which do not result in death, and towards full abolition for all crimes. 

ADPAN urges the Government of Malaysia to:

  1. Abolish the death penalty for drug trafficking now. Amend section 39B of the Dangerous Drugs Act 1952 to remove the death penalty, giving effect to the Committee’s position that offences which do not cause death should not be punishable by death. Repeal the statutory presumptions of possession and trafficking in section 37A, so that the burden of proof rests fully on the prosecution.
  2. Put rehabilitation at the centre of drug policy. Ensure that people serving sentences for drug offences have access to voluntary drug treatment, mental health care, and vocational training. Replace punitive messaging such as “Dadah Musuh Negara” with evidence-based public health education that treats drug dependence as a health condition and warns people how couriers are recruited and deceived.
  3. Put the moratorium into law. Pending abolition, give the moratorium on executions a statutory footing so that no one can be executed while reform is under way.
  4. Commit to full abolition. Act on the Committee’s own recommendation and commission a comprehensive study on complete abolition, with a published timeline and meaningful public consultation.
  5. Keep the doors open. Publish regular data on death sentences, the outcomes of the Act 847 resentencing exercise, and the death row population, disaggregated by offence, nationality and gender. Ensure written grounds of judgment are published in capital and serious drug cases, including how the offender’s role, vulnerabilities, and prospects of rehabilitation were weighed.
  6. Finish the Committee’s work on the justice system. Report publicly on the Sentencing Council, sentencing guidelines, and victim support measures the Committee proposed, and resource those still outstanding.
  7. Anchor reform internationally. Ratify the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and its Second Optional Protocol, and continue to vote in favour of the UN General Assembly resolution on a moratorium on the use of the death penalty.

Public Narrative Moves Away from Death Penalty in Malaysia, Study Shows

Kuala Lumpur, 27 October 2026 – KUALA LUMPUR — Study finds that public support for capital punishment in Malaysia is rapidly waning as exposure to personal stories, social media, and regional legal cases drives citizens toward supporting abolition and non-capital alternatives. According to a new policy brief launched in Parliament on 27 October 2026 by the Anti-Death Penalty Asia Network (ADPAN), the School of Arts and Social Sciences at Monash University Malaysia (SASS), and Eleos Justice at Monash Law (EJ), growing distrust in systemic justice, the disproportionate targeting of vulnerable populations, and a rising belief in rehabilitation are prompting Malaysians to reject official state narratives in favor of comprehensive criminal justice reform.

Key Findings from the Policy Brief 

  • First, participants expressed deep distrust of the institutions that administer the death penalty. They pointed to four perceived structural failures that undermine the system’s integrity: corruption within the justice system; unequal access to justice; inconsistent use of judicial discretion in death sentencing; and discriminatory enforcement of drug laws.
  • Second, participants described how poverty, marginalisation and deception draw people into low-level courier roles. Those affected include low-income households in the bottom 40% income group (B40), women facing economic insecurity, and ethnic minorities. Meanwhile, they noted that ‘kingpins’, rarely face arrest, likely protected by corruption and wealth.     
  • Third, participants observed that public support for the death penalty for drug offences has long been shaped by government narratives and media coverage that present drugs as a threat serious enough to justify execution. Social media, lived experience, and cases in Singapore and neighbouring countries have since exposed people to other views.
  • Fourth, participants believed in rehabilitation, and this belief underpinned their support for abolition. Many favoured responses that address the poverty, coercion, drug dependence and mental health problems that draw people into the drug trade. For them, the death penalty ends the possibility of reform and rehabilitation. 

“Our findings clearly demonstrate that public sentiment is no longer a legal or political barrier to abolishing the death penalty for drug trafficking,” said Dr. Thaatchaayini Kananatu, Deputy Head of School (Research) and Co-Director of Eleos Justice and co-author of the policy brief. “To turn this evidence into actionable reform, our policy brief proposes recommendations for each of Malaysia’s three branches of government: the Executive, the Legislature, and the Judiciary. Ultimately, our main recommendation is to abolish the death penalty, starting with drug crimes,”

Significance of the Policy Brief

With the enactment of the Abolition of Mandatory Death Penalty Act 2023, Malaysia’s legal system now has the discretionary death penalty for 27 offences, including drug trafficking under Section 39B of the Dangerous Drugs Act 1952 (DDA 1952). The historic resentencing process for those sentenced under the mandatory sentencing framework combined with the introduction of judicial discretion has drastically decreased the death row population 1,275 individuals in 2023 to 140 by January 2025 and further declined to 97 in November 2025. As of 2025, individuals convicted of drug offences constitute 21% of those on death row.

“Malaysia should be commended for its important progress in reforming its death penalty laws. Ending the mandatory death penalty and resentencing those on death row has dramatically reduced the number of people facing execution,” said Sara Kowal, Director of EJ, Deputy Co-Convenor of ADPAN, and co-author of the policy brief. “But we know that in practice the death penalty falls on the most vulnerable: people living in poverty, people from marginalised communities and people living with disabilities. Abolishing the death penalty for drug offences is a pragmatic next step, and one that recognises that executing people for drug offences breaches international human rights law.”

What’s Next?

The policy brief launch presented the study’s key findings and recommendations to parliamentarians, government officials, and key stakeholders. By showcasing the research evidence and sharing perspectives on reform, the event aimed to foster ongoing policy engagement toward abolishing the death penalty for drug offenses.

“Our goal is for this policy brief to serve as a foundation for ADPAN’s advocacy towards the abolition of the death penalty, starting with abolition for drug offences in Malaysia,” said Ngeow Chow Ying, ADPAN’s Deputy Co-Convenor. “By examining the narratives and arguments that shape discussions around drug-related offences and the death penalty, the research helps us better understand how these issues are framed and how we can communicate the case for abolition more effectively. We will use these findings to inform our advocacy messaging and campaign strategy, and to engage parliamentarians, BHEUU and legal partners with evidence-based arguments to build a united front for reform,”

Methodology 

Between May and July 2026, Monash University Malaysia hosted five ethics-approved focus group discussions (FGDs) to explore public views on the death penalty for drug trafficking. Involving 31 key stakeholders including youth, civil society representatives, professionals, entrepreneurs, and leaders across five major religious groups (Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Christianity, and Sikhism). The study examined the beliefs shaping these opinions and identified what participants consider fair and effective drug policies.

ADPAN Statement on Malaysia’s Progress in Death Penalty Reform and Indefinite Juvenile Detention

ADPAN Statement on Malaysia's Progress in Death Penalty Reform and Indefinite Juvenile Detention

March 13, 2025, Statements

The Anti-Death Penalty Asia Network (ADPAN) commends Malaysia’s historic steps towards reducing the use of the death penalty. Shifting from a mandatory sentencing framework to a discretionary one has had a significant impact: recent parliamentary data [1] reveals that, after resentencing hearings took place between November 2023 and October 2024, the number of people on death row dramatically declined from more than 1300 [2] to 140. Allowing the Federal Court of Malaysia to review each sentence and to consider mitigating factors has given second chances to many people previously condemned to death and signals a crucial move away from capital punishment as a default.

Further, this has paved the way for better compliance with international human rights standards and the adoption of a rehabilitative, rather than a punitive, approach to justice. ADPAN commends the work of the dedicated capital defence lawyers, the Malaysian Bar, civil society organisations, and others whose efforts ensured that all those eligible for resentencing were able to be represented before the Court.

Progress: Significant Decline in Death Sentences

According to Parliamentary data and records from the Malaysian Prisons Department, the number of people on death row in Malaysia has significantly declined, including a sharp drop in the proportion of women. As of 22 January 2025 the proportion of women on death row fell from 9.65% in 2022 [3] to just 1.43% in 2025. In 2022, the World Coalition Against the Death Penalty reported that Malaysia had 129 women on death row, making it the country with the highest number of women sentenced to death based on available data [4]. That number has now fallen to two women, along with one individual whose gender identity is unclear from publicly available data. This decline means that Malaysia is now aligned with the global average, where women typically make up 1–5% of death row populations [5]. It marks a significant milestone in addressing the disproportionate impact of the death penalty on women in Malaysia, many of whom were convicted of drug-related offences under coercive or exploitative circumstances.

The number of foreign nationals sentenced to death in Malaysia has also significantly declined—the data shows that there are now 27 foreign nationals on death row [6] (19.3%). This is a notable drop from previous years: in February 2019, Amnesty International reported 568 (44%) foreign nationals on death row, of which 73% had been convicted of drug trafficking [7].

While this decline reflects ongoing reforms and evolving sentencing practices, concerns persist regarding fair trial rights and access to legal representation for foreign nationals facing capital punishment.

Death Penalty for Drug Offences

Despite progress in reducing the overall number of people on death row, serious concerns remain. Nearly one-third of persons remaining on death row (40 people) have been convicted of drug offences [8]. Drug offences do not meet the international legal threshold of “most serious crimes” set by Article 6 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which has been interpreted as referring to “crimes of extreme gravity involving intentional killing” [9]. A number of UN bodies, including the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime [10] and the International Narcotics Control Board [11], have called for States to abolish the death penalty for drug offences. We urge the Government of Malaysia to review its position on retaining the death penalty for drug offences and consider an evidence-based drug policy that ‘promotes prevention, treatment, rehabilitation and reintegration’ [12].

Mitigation Review 

We urge the authorities to ensure that the 140 persons still facing the death penalty are given mitigation reviews with full consideration of mitigating factors that may not have been presented at the time of their original sentencing or during the resentencing process. Failure to consider such factors has been widely recognized as leading to unjust and disproportionate sentences. International human rights standards, including Article 14(1) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), affirms that everyone is entitled to a fair and public hearing by a competent, independent, and impartial tribunal. A fair and just legal process must recognize the individual circumstances of each case and align with international human rights standards. In this regard, we recommend that Malaysia consider establishing a mitigation system according to clear and accepted standards developed along themes of mitigating circumstances. 

Indefinite Juvenile Detention 

Malaysia’s commitment to legal reform must go beyond the death penalty and tackle other deep-seated injustices—particularly the indefinite detention of juvenile offenders under Section 97(2) of the Child Act 2001 [13]. According to the latest parliamentary data [14], 27 juvenile offenders have been sentenced under this provision:  

  • 11 individuals have been imprisoned for over 10 years
  • 12 individuals have been imprisoned for 10 to 20 years
  • 2 individuals have been detained for more than 20 years

Children sentenced to indefinite detention are given annual reviews, but there is no clear path to release, violating Articles 37(b) and 40(1) of the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC). The CRC mandates that detention be a last resort, for the shortest period, and that juvenile justice promotes dignity, rehabilitation, and reintegration. However, discretionary powers over release rest with the Yang di-Pertuan Agong, rulers, or governors, with little transparency in the review process, raising concerns about prolonged imprisonment and lack of due process. 

Worryingly, these individuals sentenced as children have been excluded from resentencing under the Resentencing Act 2023, leaving them trapped in a system that contradicts Malaysia’s commitments to juvenile justice reform and human rights. should abolish indefinite detention for juvenile offenders, review these cases under Malaysia’s 2023 legal reforms, and adopt rehabilitative justice models in line with the principle of the best interests of the child and international best practices.

Prospects for Reform: Our Continuing Call

While Malaysia’s criminal justice reforms signal significant progress, true justice requires a holistic and rights-based approach that extends beyond death penalty abolition to broader systemic reforms. We remain committed to working alongside civil society, legal practitioners, and policymakers to advocate for a fair, humane, and just criminal justice system

[1] First Meeting of the Fourth Session of the Fifteenth Parliament, 2025 (3 February – 6 March 2025), Question No. 1–721 

[2] Martin Carvalho, Rahimy Rahim, and Tarrence Tan, “Over 1,000 Inmates on Death Row May Be Spared the Gallows Following New Law,” The Star, April 3, 2023, https://www.thestar.com.my

[3]  ‘Mapping of Women on Death Row’, Report, World Coalition Against the Death Penalty, August 2023, p16, https://worldcoalition.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/ENG_Country-Mapping-report_Women-on-Death-Row.pdf

[4]  ‘Mapping of Women on Death Row’, Report, World Coalition Against the Death Penalty, August 2023, p16, https://worldcoalition.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/ENG_Country-Mapping-report_Women-on-Death-Row.pdf

[5] Cornell Center on the Death Penalty Worldwide, Judged for More Than Her Crime: A Global Overview of Women Facing the Death Penalty, (September 2018), https://deathpenaltyworldwide.org/publication/judged-more-than-her-crime/

[6] First Meeting of the Fourth Session of the Fifteenth Parliament, 2025 (3 February – 6 March 2025), Question No. 1–721 

[7] Amnesty International, Fatally Flawed: Why Malaysia Must Abolish the Death Penalty, 2019, p. 5

[8]  First Meeting of the Fourth Session of the Fifteenth Parliament, 2025 (3 February – 6 March 2025), Question No. 1–721

[9]  Article 6(2) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights; Safeguard No.1 of the UN Safeguards guaranteeing protection of the rights of those facing the death penalty, adopted through UN Economic and Social Council resolution 1984/50.

[10] United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), ‘Statement Attributable to the UNODC Spokesperson on the Use of the Death Penalty’ (Press Release, 27 June 2019) https://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/press/releases/2019/June/statement-attributable-to-the-unodc-spokesperson-on-the-use-of-the-death-penalty.html

[11]  Report of the International Narcotics Control Board for 2021, UN DOC. E/INCB/2021/1, para. 96.

[12] United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), ‘Statement Attributable to the UNODC Spokesperson on the Use of the Death Penalty’ (Press Release, 27 June 2019) https://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/press/releases/2019/June/statement-attributable-to-the-unodc-spokesperson-on-the-use-of-the-death-penalty.html

[13] Section 97(2) Child Act 2001

[14] Malaysia, House of Representatives, Response by the Minister of Home Affairs to Question No. 552 by Tuan Chow Yu Hui (Raub) during the First Meeting, Fourth Session, Fifteenth Parliament, January 22, 2025, Notice of Question in the House of Representatives

 

 

MALAYSIA CASE STUDY: REZA MOHAMMED SHAH BIN AHMAD SHAH

Malaysia Case Study: Reza Mohammed Shah Bin Ahmad Shah

Reza Mohammed Shah Bin Ahmad Shah, known as Reza Shah, was arrested by police on the evening of 14 August 2000 in a squatter neighbourhood outside Kuala Lumpur. Police said he was carrying a plastic bag which he threw away when they called out to him. Police located the plastic bag and said it contained almost 800g of cannabis. Reza Shah denied any knowledge of the bag’s contents and stated in court that the police had beaten him to force him to reveal its location. 

After arrest, Reza Shah was held at Brickfields Police District Headquarters, a police station which has been the subject of repeated allegations of torture and other ill-treatment. Reza Shah was detained pending trial for two years and finally tried in August 2002. He was found guilty by the High Court of Kuala Lumpur of possessing 795.3g of cannabis under the Dangerous Drugs Act 1952….

In the case of Reza Shah, once the trial court found that he possessed drugs in the alleged quantities, the law as it stood at that time left the court with no discretion but to convict him of trafficking and then to hand down the mandatory death sentence. 

In 2006, the Putrajaya Appeal Court overturned the trial court’s verdict. It held that the prosecution had not proved that Reza Shah had knowledge of the bag’s contents. It convicted him for possession of drugs only but not of trafficking, and sentenced him to a jail term of 18 years and 10 strokes of the cane. In January 2009, the Federal Court overturned the Appeal Court’s judgement in response to an appeal by the prosecution, concluding that Reza Shah had failed to prove that he was not guilty of drug trafficking. It reinstated the death sentence. Reza Shah has exhausted all his legal avenues for appeal. He has since appealed to the King to commute his sentence. A decision is pending. 

ADPAN: When Justice Fails – Thousands executed in Asia after unfair trials, (2011), p22 (https://adpandotnet.files.wordpress.com/2011/11/adpan-unfair-trials-asa-010232100-final-pdf.pdf)